This website uses cookies

Read our Privacy policy and Terms of use for more information.

The Daily Vroom

What Happens When The Same Car Goes To Auction Twice?

I have always wondered what happens when the same car comes back to auction for a second time.

Does it usually make more? Does waiting help? Does putting miles on it hurt more than people think? Does changing auction house make any difference? And if the first sale happened in a packed room, what happens when that exact same car comes back online?

Selling a car and getting a result is never an exact science. There are too many variables, from the condition and mileage to the seller, photographs, timing, audience, venue and sometimes just whether two people decide they desperately want the same car on the same day.

But when you have enough cars, patterns start to appear.

This is something GoAskSam is already starting to surface in the current product. When a car in Find has appeared before, you can see the Sold before flag, open its Auction history and look at the previous sales behind the range Sam is showing you.

So I wanted to take that a lot further.

I ran auction results going back to 2017 through GoAskSam and matched individual cars by chassis number, so that every car whose second sale landed in the last five years could be set against its first..

15,734 cars qualified.

And boy did we get some results I did not necessarily expect.

This is exactly where I want GoAskSam going. Not just telling you what a car has sold for, but what happened to that exact car before, what happened when cars like it came back, and what seemed to make the difference the second time around.

The same engine behind every Market-Check answer now takes questions like this one from auction houses, insurers and dealers, and there is big news on that next week.

Across all 15,734 cars, the first answer is fairly simple. The second sale usually brought a little less.

The typical car returned to auction just over a year later, with a median 12.2 months between sales, and sold for 95.7% of its previous price. Only 41% managed to sell for more the second time.

So if the plan is to buy something at auction, enjoy it for a year and assume you can simply put it back through and get your money back, the numbers say you should probably think again.

But that is only the headline, because once you start digging into which cars did well, how many miles they covered and where they were sold the second time, things get much more interesting.

From the room to the screen

This was the result that surprised me most.

There were 944 cars that first sold at a traditional live auction and later came back for sale online.

The typical second sale came in at 112.9% of the first price, with almost 65% selling for more.

Compare that with the 12,002 cars that sold online both times. Those came back at just 94.8% of their first result, with 38.3% selling for more.

That is not a small difference, so my first thought was the obvious one. Surely the live-to-online group must be full of Ferraris, Porsches and expensive collector cars that had simply appreciated while the owner waited.

So we tried to break the result.

Take Ferrari and Porsche out completely and the live-to-online cars still came back at 111.1% of their first sale, with 62% selling for more.

The same makes that stayed online came back at just 93.7%, with 36.4% selling for more.

Then we compared the same makes against each other wherever there were enough cars to make a meaningful comparison, and live to online came out ahead in 10 of the 11 makes.

Bentley was the only exception.

We then looked by price, how long the car was held, the year it came back and even the season it sold in. The pattern kept showing up, and when price and holding period were combined, live to online came out ahead in all 16 comparable groups.

At some point you have to stop calling that a coincidence.

And the quickest returns did best

This was the bit that really threw me.

You would think the best results came from someone buying a car at a live auction, putting it away for two or three years and then benefiting from a rising market.

They did not. The strongest group was actually the cars that moved from a live auction to an online sale within six months.

Those came back at a typical 116% of the first sale price, and 75% sold for more.

The longer-held groups did not beat that. Across the four holding periods, the live-to-online results were 116%, 107%, 109% and 113%.

So the quick-return group was not being carried by the others, and these were not all million-dollar cars either. Cars under $25,000 were actually more heavily represented in that quick-return group than they were across the full live-to-online sample.

That makes me think there is something more interesting going on than simple market appreciation.

Think about the difference between the two environments.

At a live auction, a car may have a few minutes in front of the room. The bidder either raises the paddle or does not.

Online, that same car can sit in front of buyers for at least 7 days. People can study the photographs, go through the history, ask questions, read comments, research previous sales and decide how badly they actually want it.

That is my interpretation, not something the data can prove, but it raises a fascinating possibility.

Maybe some cars are not simply being sold twice.

Maybe they are being exposed to two completely different markets.

Going the other way was nowhere near as impressive

If the lesson were simply that changing venue helps, then cars moving from online to live should show something similar.

They did not.

Cars that sold online first and then went to a live auction came back at a typical 101.3% of the first result, so basically flat.

At the expensive end the difference becomes even harder to ignore. For cars first sold above $250,000, moving online to live produced a typical second result of only 92.1% of the first price.

The cars moving live to online in that same price band came back at 118.5%, with 70% selling for more.

Now, before anyone reads that as "online auctions are always better," that is not what the data says.

Owners choose which cars to move, we do not see every car that stayed in the live-auction world, and there will always be differences in condition, motivation and presentation that the numbers cannot fully capture.

But if I owned a car that had already crossed a live block and I was thinking about selling it again, I would absolutely be looking at this.

The car itself still matters

There was no magic switch where every car suddenly made more money online.

Ferrari was exceptional. The 65 Ferraris that moved from live to online came back at a median 128.1% of their first sale price.

Porsche was not far behind at 122.5%.

Bentley went the other way, at just 86.8%.

So what you own still matters enormously.

Looking at all repeat sales, not just those moving from live to online, Ferrari was one of the few major makes where the typical second result was actually higher than the first, at 104.5%.

Porsche was almost perfectly flat at 100.3%.

At model level, the Ferrari Testarossa really stood out. The typical repeat sale came back at 125.6% of the first price, with almost eight in ten selling for more.

The Ferrari 355 and 430 also performed strongly, along with the Acura NSX, Porsche 964 and Ford GT.

At the other end, the Bentley Continental GT came back at just 84.3% of its previous sale.

Same basic question, completely different answer depending on what sits in the garage.

One caveat here is that model names are not always recorded consistently from one auction house to another, so I would put much more weight on the make-level results than on individual model rankings.

The 1980s held up best

There was another pattern I liked.

Cars from the 1980s held their value better than any other decade, with the 1990s close behind.

The weakest group was cars from the 2020s, where fewer than three in ten managed to beat their previous result.

That actually makes a lot of sense. A nearly-new car returning to auction is often still depreciating, while a desirable car from the 1980s is being bought for a completely different reason.

It is another reminder that talking about "the collector-car market" as if it is one thing does not really work.

There are dozens of markets sitting inside it.

Then there are the miles

This may be the most useful finding for anyone who actually owns one of these cars.

Cars that returned after adding fewer than 500 miles generally stayed reasonably close to their previous result.

But once the car had covered more than 10,000 additional miles, the typical second sale fell to just 82.5% of the first price, and fewer than one in four managed to sell for more.

We spend a lot of time talking about whether the market is going up or down, whether spring is better than winter and whether someone should wait another year before selling.

Meanwhile, there is a number quietly ticking upwards every time you take the car out of the garage.

For resale, that number may matter far more.

And what if you turned down the high bid?

This is another one I think sellers will enjoy.

We found 1,224 cars that failed to meet reserve and were later sold.

In 77% of those cases, the eventual selling price was higher than the high bid the seller had previously turned down.

Typically, by around 10%.

There is an important caveat.

This only includes cars that eventually came back and sold. A car that failed to meet reserve, disappeared and was never seen again is obviously not included.

So this is not permission for every seller to stubbornly refuse the market.

But among the cars where we can actually see what happened next, the person in the comments shouting "you should have taken the money" was usually wrong.

I like that one.

And this is why auction history matters

The part I find most exciting is that this does not have to remain a giant historical study.

When you are looking at a car in GoAskSam today, you can already see when it has sold before, open its auction history and go straight into the previous sales behind it.

That changes how I look at a listing.

A current bid on its own tells you very little. Knowing the same car sold before, what it made, where it sold, how long ago it happened and what has changed since then gives you a completely different picture.

And that is where this gets useful rather than simply interesting.

Because the next question is not just:

What did this car sell for before?

It is:

What usually happened to cars like this when they came back?

So what would I actually take away from all of this?

If you want the simple answer, selling the same car twice usually means getting slightly less the second time.

But the simple answer is probably the least interesting thing we found.

What you own matters. The era matters. The miles you add can hurt badly. Turning down a weak bid often worked out. And, most surprisingly to me, cars that moved from a live auction to an online sale behaved completely differently from the wider repeat-sale market.

944 cars made that move. Their typical second result was 112.9% of the first, and almost two thirds sold for more.

We tried pretty hard to make that result disappear by removing Ferrari and Porsche, comparing similar makes, splitting the cars by price, holding period, year and season.

It kept coming back.

That still does not mean selling online caused the higher price. Selling cars will never be that exact.

But if I see that little Sold before badge on a car now, I am looking at it rather differently.

Because the previous sale is not just history.

Sometimes it is the most useful clue to what might happen next.

And that is exactly the sort of thing I want GoAskSam answering.

Big news on that next week.

In the meantime, if you haven’t tried GoAskSam yet, give it a go. It’s completely free to use.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate